GBAMFS on Players' Alliance HQ

Players' Alliance HQ
Astroturf $CAM

Players' Alliance HQ is just another astroturf scam propped up by an industry dead-set against change.

GBAMFS's position on Players' Alliance HQ. Independent commentary; no affiliation.

They're not players, they're just trying to play you.

Don’t be fooled by this astroturf scam group of disgruntled, woke ex-employees and hired influencers.
PlayersAllianceHQ suggests these streamers — Twitch screenshot

This is GBAMFS's view of Players' Alliance HQ. We look at who they say they are, who we are, and why we see a clear difference.

Who they are

Players’ Alliance HQ (PAHQ) wants to speak for gamers. So far, its strongest case for the job is that it knows how to throw a protest, run a stream, and put “players” in its name.

PAHQ is a recent group that rose to prominence by protesting and streaming against the Saudi-backed buyout of Electronic Arts. Its public pitch now covers much more: owning the games we buy, fair prices, better jobs for developers, and less power for big publishers. Some of that sounds familiar because we’ve been making the case for gamers’ rights for years. What stands out is how easily the list shifts from what customers are owed to what industry workers and organized labor want.

Players' Alliance HQ source image 1Players' Alliance HQ source image 2Players' Alliance HQ source image 3

The public record is short. PAHQ’s domain was registered on May 22, 2025. Its YouTube account joined on June 16, a Facebook image update is dated August 6, and its subreddit opened on October 29. Some of that online footprint predates the buyout announcement. The early site capture we have shows what PAHQ chose to lead with: stopping the EA deal.

WHOIS record for Players’ Alliance HQ(View domain record)
Players’ Alliance HQ site in January 2026
The first appearance of their site was single-purpose. This group was created to oppose the Saudi acquisition of EA. Does this look like a sock-puppet move to you? Because it sure does to us...

PAHQ also says it is separate from The Players Alliance, the baseball group. Its posts call on people to block the EA deal. The supplied images show forms, rally posts, signs, and clips shared across social sites. Those posts show how it seeks support. They do not show who pays for it.

Instagram screenshot 1Instagram screenshot 3Instagram screenshot 2

That’s a campaign. When did it become a mandate to speak for gamers? Who put this group together? Who funds it? And when Stop Killing Games gave PAHQ a seat at its town hall, what track record did it see that the rest of us were supposed to take on trust?

Start with the dated record. Compare what GBAMFS was doing years before PAHQ appeared, what each group says it stands for, and whose interests each puts first.

The Timeline

The timeline brings the dates, site captures, and town hall questions together. The sections that follow set out our history and the comparison in detail.

The chronology side by side

GBAMFS, PAHQ, and Stop Killing Games milestone timeline

Out of nowhere, in late '25, 2026,
PLAYERSALLIANCEHQ

Earlier Players’ Alliance HQ page
THEIR “Who We Are” versus Real People. Real passion.
Players’ Alliance HQ Who We Are GBAMFS Who We Are

Why we stayed independent

We spoke with Stop Killing Games (SKG) about affiliating. We decided against it after Jdawg spoke with Moritz Katzner. As Jdawg put it, he “smelled a rat.”

We’ve seen how corrupt this industry can be. Here in the U.S., we know regulatory capture is real: the industries a regulator is meant to oversee can gain influence over it. Astroturfing can give industry or government interests a similar foothold in groups and campaigns that draw their strength from public support.

If we put our work under SKG’s banner, we’d risk losing control of it if outside interests gained influence over its leadership or if the campaign drifted from its original mission. What we’re seeing makes that risk harder to dismiss. More on that later.

What's Stop Killing Games up to now?

SKG had one core goal: keep the games people paid for playable after publishers stop supporting them. Its European citizens’ initiative gathered 1,294,188 verified statements of support. So far, those backers haven’t gotten a binding requirement to keep their games playable. In its June 2026 reply, the European Commission said it would pursue an industry code of conduct.

Now SKG is widening its focus. Players’ Alliance HQ is advertising a November 18, 2026 town hall with SKG on game ownership and consumer rights. We see that as a broader agenda while the original goal remains unresolved.

Stop Killing Games town hall announcement

They were invited, we weren't. In spite of helping SKG before, on all Gamers' behalf

GBAMFS California AB 1921 information packet

You can see our brief in support of SKG's California Bill work, which was done volunteer and with virtually no recognition on SKG's part. We can now maybe see why that is. You can read our brief here.

What we asked SKG to do: We asked SKG to investigate the apparent ethical misconduct and conflicts of interest involving PAHQ and to select a different group for the town hall. We’re conducting our own investigation.

Who we are - How it started

Mexican Pepe, Star Destroyer, and retro PC gaming avatars in decorative frames

Starting in 2020, a group of friends and disappointed customers came together online. We were gamers who were fed up with how some game firms treated us. We came together to seek redress: to push those firms to put things right.

We wanted good games and fair treatment. Our domain record lists January 15, 2020. Our early mission said that gaming was more than a hobby. It was part of our lives, and we wanted to help shape its future.

GBAMFS beginnings — domain registration record

That mission named the problems we saw: loot boxes, small payments piled into games, poor releases, and bad customer service. It also called out games built to keep us spending. We aimed to teach players about these issues, press for change, and help promising game makers.

GBAMFS beginnings — supporting screenshot

Although we started as an anonymous group, and our site began as a form of protesting these abuses of players' patience and love of our artform - gaming - it grew to become something much more.

And no longer anonymous

When COVID passed, with Jdawg carrying the torch, we re-emerged

Jdawg with his gaming collection
JdawgKaiSigma, the hand-written author of the Mission Statement (Our FAQ is entirely hand-crafted and also his work) Jdawg signature

The principles we carried forward

Our FAQ goes back to 2024. It set out F.A.I.R.: Fun, Accountability, Innovation, Responsibility. These ideas came from our 2020 work. They ask for games that are fun, firms that answer for what they do, fresh ideas, and care for others.

The framework covers players' rights, game makers' duties and protections, buyers' duties and protections, and checks on firms and markets. Each part matters. We want fair treatment for the people who make games and the people who buy them.

Hear our founder Jdawg speaking on principles that matter to us, and what our goals are in the scene
Our FAQ · 2024Our FAQ · 2024

We revised the FAQ in July 2025. The July 18 archive image shows that version. It says buyers should own what they buy and get their games in a fair amount of time. It also says game workers deserve decent conditions. The dates matter: our roots are in 2020, the FAQ goes back to 2024, and the page shown here was revised in 2025.

Some examples of our work

We've been consistent defending Gamers' interests throughout

The revised FAQ · July 2025The revised FAQ · July 2025

Our return in 2024

After a break, we returned in 2024 to help defend Kabrutus. We brought the same goals with us: stand up for gamers, speak out about bad practices, and work for change.

The problems that led us to form the group had not gone away. Players still needed a voice and a way to push back. Our return put those goals back into action.

The 2024 return · Kabrutus

Who is Kabrutus?

Kabrutus is a Brazilian Gamer who created the 'Sweet Baby Inc Detected' group on the Steam Forums. Since he wasn't a fan of games they had worked on, he did this as a curator effort to raise awareness and inform other gamers on which games they had a part in working on.

While you may or may not share his taste in games, or views on the work of the SBI consultancy, it goes without saying he had every right to do that. It's a basic part of the principles of Free Expression our group, GBAMFS stands for. Consumer feedback and artistic criticism / curation is essential to the function of markets, platforms, and artistic communities (including pop-art consumers, like Gamers often are!)

Kabrutus case reference image 1 Kabrutus case reference image 2

The group he created

The Purpose of the Group

The group was simply there to document the involvement of the Sweet Baby Inc consultancy firm, which had been involved in a number of games that were viewed with skepticism and met with tepid market reactions up to that point (no major failures up to then, but that would come later.)

While Kabrutus had more offhand reasons for rejecting the group's work, the principle purpose of this curator profile on Steam was to inform consumers and raise visibility of the fact of SBI's role. While most would use it for its intended function and avoid the games, it is not inconceivable that the increased visibility would also send fans of their work to their other projects. In any case, the exposure was treated with hostility by one of the employees at SBI, which we can see featured here:

SBI Detected

The fundamental issues at stake are clear, just as they were then: Consumer awareness and customer feedback are core to not only informed buying, but the Free Market and Free Expression principles that underlying them itself.

By attacking a Gamer who simply voiced his opinion about disliking the games SBI was involved with and sought to inform others about their work, Kindred was in effect trying to gag someone for exercising the cherished American tradition of Free Speech.

Kabrutus was providing a service to the gaming community. By seeking to deprive him of his games and platform access, SBI's employee would also have silenced feedback that proved broadly popular, as subsequent interest showed, and eliminated an avenue for artistic criticism and informed consumption. It could also have amounted to theft by deprivation: using the platform to deny a critic access to products he paid for.

It's one example of many where Free Speech is jeopardized to protect corporate and corporate-adjacent privileges. It's why we view that as core to our work.

It seems to strike at the heart of Stop Killing Games’ claimed mission, too.

The same ownership question is at stake: if a platform can take away games someone paid for because they criticized a company, what does that purchase actually guarantee?

How can this be, SKG?

The difference

Our record starts with gamers who joined together in 2020 to seek fair treatment. We returned in 2024 and kept building on those goals. PAHQ later put forward a set of ideas that closely matches ours. We see this as a lightly changed copy of our words and principles.

Both texts start with a love of games. Both turn to harm caused by firms, fair treatment for players and workers, and the need to act together. Our FAQ says buyers should own what they buy. PAHQ calls for digital ownership rights. Our mission challenges loot boxes and pressure to spend; PAHQ calls for fair prices and clear terms. Our FAQ covers workers and checks on firms; PAHQ lists worker rights and limits on corporate power.

First, see Player Alliance HQ's Mission Statement, taken from Reddit

Player Alliance HQ mission statement on Reddit
Compare the prose and principles Side-by-side comparison of GBAMFS and Players Alliance HQ prose and principles

Follow the breadcrumbs. In GBAMFS’s mission statement, visible in the January 2022 archive capture, we wrote: “Gaming is more than a hobby.” The PAHQ Reddit mission post, shown here alongside its October 2025 community record, opens with the same idea: “gaming is more than just a hobby for most of us.” Both move from what gaming means to players, to monetization practices they oppose, to a call for organized action. That sequence is the strongest overlap we see. The wording and dates show the resemblance and who said it first in the records shown here. Whether PAHQ drew directly from our work is our inference.

(Click to Enlarge)

What's missing?

The most notable omission is the most telling: Our group makes Free Expression an 'open comms,' a point of principal interest. We believe in Free Speech! It's core to Gamer culture, where casual and free-wheeling self-expression is part of our jam. When it goes, fun often gets downshifted or cut out entirely in short order afterwards.

While we respect the principle for platforms to moderate, that often is only done to the point of excluding often male-centric forms of humor and self-expression. Not every gaming space will be a 'Safe Space,' in the sense that your feelings are the top priority for other players' to respect, even if that might be ideal or indicated in certain environments. For example platforms that exclusively are rated 'G' / General Audiences, pre-teen and games for which foul language would be generally thought inappropriate (Chess matches, puzzle co-op, kid-focused sandbox environments.)

We find it super curious and telling that of all the positions PAHQ decided to copy - THAT isn't one!

Open Comms, and candid self-expression are core to Gamer culture. If you missed that, you probably aren't too in touch with what makes the scene true and authentic to many

These are the issues we bring to light here, linking our positions, prose and concerns with their apparent special interest misappropriation of work we've been doing in this space far longer (to much less fanfare!) The simply overlap in goals doesn't itself prove the copycat. It's the summation of things and circumstances of their elevation in the impending SKG Town Hall event, where our group, which previously supported SKG and was considered for affiliation (declined on our part out of concern for the hazard of a monopoly 'movement' umbrella) - only to find ourselves looking at a facsimile assembled out of the ashes of a failed pop-up 'turf attempt to prevent EA's acquisition.

Our charge rests on the way the ideas, wording, and order fit together. We regard PAHQ's pitch as an attempt to take attention from work that we've done and which comes from the heart. We don't see them as having the same core interests and that is why we call it astroturf: our view is that its claim to speak for ordinary gamers does not match the role it seeks to play.

Players' Alliance issues, priorities

  • CEO Pay
  • Anti-AI
  • Pay / Wage Gap
  • Anti-Private Equity
  • Anti-EA buyout
  • Anti-Monopoly
  • Anti-Crunch (per se)
  • Pro-"Diversity" (please see our page Gamers are Diverse!)

IF this reads to you like a wishlist of Union agenda items...

WE CONTEND- THAT'S BECAUSE IT'S EXACTLY WHAT IT IS!

To all appearances, this is just union-aligned special interest group squatting on the Gamer Consumer Interest space for their own purposes

And we just can't let that slide!

While many of these issues share some overlap with of Gamers' general concerns and in specific areas may indeed prove the same, as starting points, these are non-starters. These are industry-aligned demands snuck in under the cover of a Gamer Consumer campaign.

We've always been up front about the ground-up, grass-roots nature of OUR work, and that while developers are allies in this fight in many cases, we don't claim to BE developers ourselves, except where, and as that may actually apply (some of us and our supporters are, but most are not.)

Gamers' issues + priorities

  • Own and keep the games we buy. Preserve playability, support real physical copies, and reform license terms.
  • Protect free expression and artistic freedom. Keep comms open and protect honest criticism and creative choice.
  • Get what we paid for. Expect timely delivery, products fit for sale, and fair refunds.
  • Expect responsibility from developers and publishers. Deliver on commitments and provide decent working conditions.
  • Use our power as buyers. Share candid feedback and support studios that deliver good games and treat players fairly.
  • Keep markets open. Protect platform choice, repair, modding, and access to payment services. Scrutinize conduct that restricts competition.
  • Make room for innovation. Explore tools like AI and support creators who prefer established methods.
  • Recognize the diversity already in gaming. Celebrate the people who play and make games, and defend artistic freedom.

Read the GBAMFS FAQ and F.A.I.R. principles

The ethics of this are poor on PAHQ's part and one of our core principles, under the F.A.I.R. doctrine, among other items, is to bring more integrity and open communication on commercial practices, reporting, private actors actions in the industry space, and so on.

We can, and no group claiming similar principles can, begin to suggest they're serious about this starting on the kind of footing Players' Alliance has!

Who are they really?

Action Network screenshot

They're part of a politically Progressive network of funded orgs

They claim they're separate from Players Alliance (Baseball) group

But why choose such a similar name? Who created this group? Who funds them?

The namealike group, Players' Alliance (baseball,) which touts 'Equity and Diversity' as chief goals for its group, has Margarita Ortiz as its Executive Administrator. Margarita has previously worked as a receptionist for Soros Fund Management. The Soros family are well-known for their political involvement in far-left political activist causes.

Margarita Ortiz professional profile and work history

While HQ claims this is a totally separate group, the similarity in name, and some underlying goals, would seem to suggest that while formal affiliation may not be established, ideological conformity certainly is.

Their explanation of the difference between the two groups

Players Alliance HQ page distinguishing itself from the baseball group

Meanwhile, their first protest was held in Madison, Wisconsin. It's a noted hub for far-leftwing political activism and activity.

Facebook screenshot about the Madison, Wisconsin protest

It's easy to get a crowd together there to protest. Or routinely meet up in communal spaces - for any purpose. Does that crowd have any real connection, love and affection for gaming? That's the real question here. It's no Litmus Test on their ideals per se. It matters because Gamers need to know we aren't being taken for a ride by deep-pocketed, dark money interest groups that can spare the change to throw together protests and pay streamers.

Instagram screenshot 5 Instagram screenshot 7

What does this mean for the average gaming consumer? You gotta ask yourself that question!

Players' Alliance HQ was created hastily to oppose the Saudi acquisition of Electronic Arts, that much is clear. Virtually everything about the group otherwise isn't. They've misappropriated our own likeness and positions, not to mention our very Mission Statement to advance their own agenda. We believe that should be treated as suspect at the very least.

In Summary - Table Comparison

GBAMFS versus Players’ Alliance HQ comparison table
BEPIS dog and cola with a pink prohibition symbol

Our advocacy today

We fight for you every day, talking to devs and industry, hearing from gamers their concerns and keeping a watchful eye on current events dominating the news

GBAMFS team portraits framed in gold within a granite gaming memorial

Our work goes on. We still seek fair treatment, better games, and changes to how the industry treats players. We will keep doing that work despite campaigns like this one, which we regard as astroturf.

We judge groups by their record and their work, not just the causes they name. We judge companies by what they deliver, not just what they say. What matters most to us is what it all means for Gamers, for our culture, and for our ability to keep playing and enjoying what we love: Video Games.

Our path runs from our 2020 founding, through our return in 2024, to the work we do today. We will defend that record and keep pushing for the changes that brought us together.

GBAMFS website

Why haven't I heard of you before?

We're suppressed on X. When we called out top-tier corruption from fake-dev Grummz, an Elon favorite, shit started to go majorly downhill for us there. And you know what? We take it in stride. If Big Gaming corruption and Elon's crooked false promises of a Free Speech platform on X can't get us down, this is just another day for us finding better-financed competitors soaking up all the glory and attention.

We do it for you Gamers. Not for bux or clicks. That's the difference

What we do

Most of our work isn't flashy, but for example:

Simulated mobile interstitial with email and phone number fields and no dismiss button
(Simulated image. The interstitial no longer appears on the site.)

After we raised ethical concerns with SKG about its affiliation with this group, we noticed a change on the Players' Alliance site. On mobile, the site used to open with an aggressive pop-up asking for an email address and phone number, with no way to dismiss it. The site now has a sign-up form on the page itself. We applaud little changes like this. Even if creators and the press pass them over, they matter to everyday Gamers.

We'll count that as one more example of the little wins we rack up.

The most important achievements most Gamers earn are those we can recognize for ourselves!

Don’t let others decide the future of your games

If gamers sit this out, Big Gaming, Big Labor, and other groups with money and access will keep setting the terms for the games we buy and the communities we build. Join GBAMFS to stand up for the right to keep the games you pay for, speak freely about them, and have a say in what comes next.

Join Us